Mathematical Operations
A mathematical operations question replaces the usual signs with new symbols or with letters, or asks the candidate to solve an equation in which the signs have been interchanged. The whole chapter depends on translating the new symbols back into the usual signs and then working the arithmetic in the right order. A candidate who writes the translation beside the question and then follows the order of operations will answer reliably.
The first kind gives a new meaning to each sign. The question may say that a plus sign means division and a division sign means plus, or that a multiplication sign means subtraction. The candidate should write the true meaning under each sign before doing anything else, and should not trust the eye, because the signs look familiar and the eye tends to read them in the usual way. Writing the translation is the whole safety of the chapter.
The second kind replaces the signs with letters, such as P for plus and Q for minus, and gives an expression in the letters. The candidate should translate each letter into its sign and then work the expression. The letters are chosen to look unlike the signs, so the candidate must be careful not to slip back into the usual reading. Writing the expression again with the real signs is a good habit.
The third kind uses a made-up operation defined by a formula, such as a star b equals a squared plus b squared, or a star b equals a plus b minus their product. The candidate should substitute the given numbers into the formula and work the arithmetic, taking care with the order of operations inside the formula. The formula is always simple, and the only risk is a slip in the arithmetic, which the candidate should check by working it twice.
The candidate must follow the order of operations, which is that brackets are worked first, then powers, then multiplication and division from left to right, and then addition and subtraction from left to right. When the signs have been changed, the order is still decided by the true signs, not by the printed ones. This is a common trap, and the candidate should write the true signs and then apply the order to them.
A useful method for a long expression is to work one step at a time and to write the expression again after each step. This keeps the working visible and prevents the candidate from losing track of which sign means what. A candidate who works in the head, with the signs interchanged, is almost certain to make a mistake, so the written step is not a waste of time but a saving of it.
Some questions ask which of several expressions is equal to a given one, or which two of a set of expressions are equal. Here the candidate should evaluate each expression and compare the values. Evaluating is slower than reasoning, but it is reliable, and with the small numbers that these questions use, the evaluation is quick. The candidate should keep the values in a column so that the comparison is easy.
A related kind asks the candidate to find the value of a missing number in an equation, with the signs interchanged. The candidate should translate the signs, write the equation in the usual form, and then solve for the missing number by the usual rules of algebra. The missing number is found by undoing the operations in reverse order, and the candidate should check the answer by putting it back into the original equation.
A candidate should also be able to handle a question that gives the value of a made-up operation and asks for the value of the operation applied to a new pair. Here the candidate should first find the rule from the given values, if the rule is not stated, and then apply it to the new pair. Finding the rule is the same as in the number series chapter, and the two chapters should be practised together.
Finally, a word about checking. Every answer in this chapter can be checked by working the expression again with the true signs, and the check takes only a few seconds. The candidate should form the habit of checking, because the commonest error is a sign slip, and a sign slip produces an answer that is among the options. With the translation written down and the check performed, the chapter becomes one of the safest in the reasoning paper.
It helps to write the translation as a small table at the top of the rough sheet, with the printed sign on the left and the true sign on the right. The candidate should then read the question through the table, replacing each sign as it is met. This method is slow only at first, and after a few questions the candidate will find that the table is written automatically and the translation is quick and safe.
When the signs are replaced by letters, the candidate should write the letters in the same table, with the letter on the left and the true sign on the right. The letters are usually chosen to be unlike the signs, such as P, Q, R and S, so the candidate must not confuse them with the signs they stand for. Writing the expression again with the true signs, and crossing out the letters, is the safest habit.
For a made-up operation, the candidate should write the formula beside the question and substitute the numbers one at a time. If the formula is a star b equals a plus b minus a times b, then two star three is two plus three minus two times three, which is five minus six, which is minus one. The candidate should work the substitution in steps and write each step, because the risk is a slip in the middle of the formula.
The candidate should watch for a formula that uses the same letter twice, such as a star b equals a times a plus b, because the candidate must square the first number and not the second. Reading the formula carefully, and writing it again in words, prevents the candidate from applying the wrong part of the formula to the wrong number. The examiner often builds a question on exactly this confusion.
A question may ask which of several expressions is the largest or the smallest, with the signs interchanged. Here the candidate should evaluate each expression and compare the values, keeping the values in a column. Estimating is not safe in this chapter, because the values are often close together, and a careless estimate may reverse the order. Evaluating each expression exactly is the reliable method.
The candidate should also be able to work a question in which the signs are interchanged in a fraction, because a fraction has an upper and a lower part and each must be translated. The candidate should translate the signs in both parts before doing any arithmetic, and should then work the upper part and the lower part separately before dividing. Working the parts separately keeps the fraction clear.
A related kind gives a set of equations with the signs interchanged and asks for the value of a letter. The candidate should translate the signs in each equation and then solve the equations in the usual way. The candidate should check the answer by putting the value back into the original equation, with the signs translated, and should make sure that the two sides are equal.
Some questions use the words more than and less than in place of the signs, and ask the candidate to arrange the signs correctly to make an equation true. Here the candidate should try the signs in a sensible order, beginning with the sign that makes the largest difference, and should test each arrangement. The candidate should keep a record of the arrangements tried, so that the same arrangement is not tried twice.
A useful check for any expression is to estimate the answer before working it, and then to compare the estimate with the worked answer. If the two are far apart, the candidate has made a slip, and should work the expression again. The estimate need not be exact, because its only purpose is to catch a large error, such as a sign that was translated the wrong way.
Finally, practise the chapter with a set of expressions in which the signs are interchanged in different ways, and work each one twice. Ten minutes of this practice makes the translation automatic and the checking habitual, so that in the examination hall the question is answered quickly and safely. The chapter is short and the marks come reliably once the translation and the order of operations are at hand.
- Write the true meaning of each sign under it before doing anything else.
- The order of operations follows the true signs, not the printed ones.
- For a made-up operation, substitute the numbers into the formula and work it twice.
- Work a long expression one step at a time and rewrite it after each step.
- For a missing number, translate the signs and then undo the operations in reverse order.
- Keep a small table with the printed sign on the left and the true sign on the right.
- For a made-up operation, substitute the numbers one at a time and write each step.
- Watch for a formula that uses the same letter twice.
- Evaluate each expression exactly when comparing values; do not estimate.
- Estimate the answer before working it, and compare the estimate with the worked answer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the safest first step in a mathematical operations question?
Write the true meaning of every sign under it before doing any arithmetic, because the eye tends to read the printed signs in the usual way.
Which order of operations applies when the signs are changed?
The order follows the true signs: brackets, powers, multiplication and division, then addition and subtraction.
How do I handle a made-up operation such as a star b?
Write the formula beside the question, substitute the numbers one at a time, and work the arithmetic in steps.
Should I estimate or evaluate exactly when comparing expressions?
Evaluate exactly. The values are often close, so an estimate may reverse the order.