Time and Work
Time and work is a chapter that rewards a single clever idea, and the ADRE Grade III paper tests it through short problems about men, machines and pipes filling and emptying tanks. The idea is that a person who can finish a job in a certain number of days does a fixed fraction of the job in one day, called the one day's work. If a man finishes a job in ten days, his one day's work is one tenth of the job. Once every worker is written as a one day's work, the problems become simple additions of fractions.
The total work can also be thought of as a number of units. If a man finishes a job in ten days, the whole job may be taken as ten units and his one day's work as one unit. Choosing the total work as the lowest common multiple of the given times makes every one day's work a whole number and removes all fractions from the arithmetic. This is the single most useful trick in the chapter and it should be used whenever the numbers are awkward.
When two workers work together, their one day's works are added. If one finishes in ten days and the other in fifteen days, their combined one day's work is one tenth plus one fifteenth, which is one sixth, so together they finish the job in six days. The time taken together is always less than the time taken by the faster worker alone, a quick check that catches many errors.
When one worker leaves partway through a job, the work is divided into stages. The first stage is the part done by all the workers together, the second stage is the part done by the remaining workers, and the two parts must add up to the whole job. Writing the stages separately, and remembering that each stage has its own number of workers and its own time, turns a confusing question into two easy ones.
Wages are shared in the ratio of the work done by each worker, which is the same as the ratio of their one day's works multiplied by the time each worked. If two workers work for the same time, the wages are shared in the ratio of their one day's works. If they work for different times, the wages are shared in the ratio of the products of their one day's works and their times. This single rule answers every wage question in the paper.
Pipes and cisterns are time and work with water instead of men. A pipe that fills a tank in a certain time has a filling rate equal to the reciprocal of that time, and a pipe that empties the tank has an emptying rate, which is subtracted from the filling rates. The net rate is the sum of the filling rates minus the sum of the emptying rates, and the time to fill the tank is the reciprocal of the net rate. The arithmetic is identical to the arithmetic of men working together.
The pipes problem has a classic form in which a leak or an emptying pipe is discovered after some time. The tank is first filled by the filling pipes for a certain time, and then the emptying pipe is opened and the net rate changes. Dividing the problem into the two periods, exactly as in the men-leaving problem, is the safe way to solve it. The idea that the amount of water filled in the first period plus the amount filled in the second period equals the capacity of the tank is the key.
A common question gives the time taken by a group of workers and asks how many workers must be added or removed to finish the job in a different time. The work is fixed, so the number of workers and the time are inversely proportional. If twice as many workers are available, the job is finished in half the time. Writing the total work as a fixed number of units and dividing by the new number of workers gives the new time at once.
Efficiency questions state that one worker is more efficient than another. An efficiency of one and a half times means that the worker does one and a half times as much work in the same time, or the same work in two thirds of the time. It is easiest to convert efficiency into a one day's work and then to use the usual addition. Comparing efficiencies directly is a source of error, so converting first is the safer route.
The relation between the number of workers, the time and the total work is that the total work equals the number of workers times the time times the efficiency. For a fixed total work, the number of workers is inversely proportional to the time. This is the same inverse proportion that appears in the chapter on ratio, and recognising it links the two chapters and saves the candidate from treating each question as new.
The most common mistakes in this chapter are worth naming. Candidates add the times instead of the rates, they forget to subtract the emptying pipe, they use the total work as one and then struggle with fractions when the lowest common multiple would have kept the numbers whole, and they share wages equally instead of in the ratio of the work done. Each of these slips is avoided by writing every worker's one day's work down before adding.
Time and work is a chapter of one idea repeated in many settings, and the idea is the one day's work. A candidate who converts every worker to a one day's work, chooses the total work as a convenient number, and adds rates rather than times will find the chapter short and dependable. The arithmetic is light, the questions carry full marks, and a week of practice is enough to make the chapter one of the quickest sources of marks in the paper.
The problems on time and work are based on the idea of the rate of work. If a person can finish a work in n days, then the work done by the person in one day is one by n, which is the rate of work. The total work is taken as one unit, and the rates of the different persons are added when they work together. This single idea solves almost all the questions on the topic.
The first type of question gives the time taken by two persons working alone and asks for the time taken when they work together. If A finishes in a days and B finishes in b days, then in one day they finish one by a plus one by b of the work, and the time taken together is a b by a plus b. The candidate should remember that the time taken together is always less than the time taken by the faster of the two persons.
The second type gives the time taken together and the time taken by one person, and asks for the time taken by the other. If A and B together finish in t days and A alone finishes in a days, then the rate of B is one by t minus one by a, and the time taken by B is the reciprocal of this rate. The candidate should be careful with the subtraction of fractions, because a small error changes the answer completely.
The third type is about the work and the wages. If two persons work together and the total wages are given, the wages are divided in the ratio of the work done by each, which is the ratio of their rates. The fourth type is about the pipes and the cisterns, which is the same as the time and work, except that a pipe that fills is a positive rate and a pipe that empties is a negative rate. The net rate is the sum of the positive rates minus the sum of the negative rates.
The fifth type is about the men and the days. The work done is proportional to the number of men and the number of days, so if the number of men is doubled, the time is halved, and if the number of days is doubled, the work is doubled. The candidate should use the formula M1 D1 by W1 equals M2 D2 by W2, where M is the number of men, D is the number of days and W is the work. This formula is used in the questions on the completion of a work by a group of men.
The final type is the question on the alternate days and the leaving of a worker. If two persons work on alternate days, the work of two days is the sum of their one-day works, and the total time is found by dividing the total work by the two-day work. If a person leaves in the middle, the work done before the leaving is subtracted from the total work, and the remaining work is finished by the other person at the other person's rate.
The candidate should also know the questions on the efficiency of the workers. If a worker is twice as efficient as another, the time taken by the first is half the time taken by the second, and their rates of work are in the ratio of two is to one. The candidate should convert the efficiency into the rate of work and then add the rates, because the work is added and not the time.
The candidate should be careful with the questions in which a work is done by a group of men, women and children. The candidate should find the rate of each type of worker and then add the rates in the proportion in which they are employed. If the question gives the work done by a certain number of men and a certain number of women, the candidate should form an equation with the rates as the unknown.
The candidate should also know the questions on the wages, in which the total wages are divided in the ratio of the work done. The work done by a person is the product of the rate and the time, so the wages are divided in the ratio of the products of the rate and the time. The candidate should be careful with the case in which the workers join or leave at different times.
The candidate should note that the work and the time are inversely proportional when the number of the workers is fixed, and the work and the number of the workers are directly proportional when the time is fixed. The candidate should use the formula M1 D1 by W1 equals M2 D2 by W2, which combines the men, the days and the work, and should check the units before the calculation.
The candidate should also know the questions on the filling and the emptying of a tank by the pipes, which is the same as the time and the work. The candidate should treat a filling pipe as a positive rate and an emptying pipe as a negative rate, and should add the rates with their signs. The candidate should also be able to find the time taken when the pipes are opened at different times.
The candidate should practise the questions on the time and the work with the fractions, because the rates are fractions and the addition of the fractions is the key step. The candidate should be able to find the work done in a given time when the rate is known, and the rate when the work and the time are known. A clear table of the rate, the time and the work for each worker makes the solution easy.
- One day's work of a worker is the reciprocal of the number of days he takes.
- The total work may be taken as the LCM of the given times to avoid fractions.
- When workers work together, their one day's works are added.
- The time taken together is less than the time taken by the fastest worker alone.
- An emptying pipe is subtracted from the filling pipes.
- For a fixed job, the number of workers is inversely proportional to the time.
- Wages are shared in the ratio of the work done.
- If A finishes a work in n days, A's one-day work = 1/n.
- A and B together: time = ab/(a+b) days.
- If A and B together take t days and A alone a days, B's time = at/(a-t).
- Pipes: filling is positive, emptying is negative.
- M1 D1 / W1 = M2 D2 / W2.
- If a worker is k times as efficient, the time taken is 1/k times and the rate is k times.
- Wages are divided in the ratio of the work done (rate × time).
- Work and time are inversely proportional for a fixed number of workers.
- Pipes: add the rates with their signs (filling positive, emptying negative).
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the total work often taken as the LCM of the given times?
Because then every worker's one day's work becomes a whole number and the arithmetic avoids fractions.
How is the time found when two workers work together?
Add their one day's works to get the combined rate, then take the reciprocal of that rate.
How do I handle a pipe that empties a tank?
Subtract its rate from the filling rates; the net rate gives the time to fill as its reciprocal.
If A can do a work in a days and B in b days, how long do they take together?
Together they take ab/(a+b) days.
What is the formula connecting men, days and work?
The formula is M1 D1 / W1 = M2 D2 / W2.
If a worker is twice as efficient as another, what is the ratio of the time taken?
If a worker is twice as efficient, the time taken by the first is half the time taken by the second, so the ratio is 1 : 2.
How are the wages divided when two persons work together?
The wages are divided in the ratio of the work done by each person, which is the ratio of the products of their rates and times.