Profit and Loss
Profit and loss is the chapter in which percentage meets money, and the ADRE Grade III paper tests it through short, practical problems about buying, selling, marking and discounting. The whole chapter rests on three prices. The cost price is what the seller pays to obtain the article. The selling price is what the buyer pays to obtain it. The marked price, also called the list price, is the price written on the label before any discount is allowed. A candidate who keeps these three prices separate will not be confused by any question in the paper.
The basic relations are short. Profit is the selling price minus the cost price, and it is positive when the article is sold for more than it cost. Loss is the cost price minus the selling price, and it is positive when the article is sold for less than it cost. The selling price is the cost price plus profit or the cost price minus loss. Every question is built by fixing two of these four quantities and asking for a third, and every answer comes from one of these relations.
The two percentages are the heart of the chapter and they must never be mixed up. Profit per cent is the profit divided by the cost price, multiplied by one hundred. Loss per cent is the loss divided by the cost price, multiplied by one hundred. Both are always calculated on the cost price, because the cost price is the money the seller has risked. A candidate who divides by the selling price instead of the cost price will get an answer that is close to the right one and therefore hard to reject, which makes this error particularly dangerous.
The multiplier method turns the percentages into single factors. A profit of r per cent means that the selling price is the cost price multiplied by one plus r over one hundred. A loss of r per cent means that the selling price is the cost price multiplied by one minus r over one hundred. Two successive trades are handled by multiplying the two factors, so a profit of ten per cent followed by a loss of ten per cent gives a net loss of one per cent, because one point one times zero point nine is zero point nine nine.
The discount is a percentage of the marked price and it is always calculated on the marked price, never on the cost price. The selling price after a discount of d per cent is the marked price multiplied by one minus d over one hundred. A question may give the marked price and the discount and ask for the selling price, or give the selling price and the discount and ask for the marked price. In either case the base is the marked price, and writing it down before calculating removes the commonest error of the chapter.
When a question says that an article is marked at a price above the cost price and then sold at a discount, two percentages are at work and they act on different bases. The marked price is first found as a percentage of the cost price, and the discount is then found as a percentage of that marked price. The final profit or loss is the difference between the selling price and the cost price, expressed as a percentage of the cost price. Working through the prices one by one, in order, is the only safe way to keep the bases straight.
The relation between cost price and selling price also gives two useful formulas. When the cost price and the profit per cent are known, the selling price is the cost price multiplied by one hundred plus the profit per cent, divided by one hundred. When the selling price and the profit per cent are known, the cost price is the selling price multiplied by one hundred, divided by one hundred plus the profit per cent. The same formulas with the profit per cent replaced by a loss per cent, subtracted instead of added, give the loss cases.
Two articles sold at the same price, one at a profit and the other at a loss of the same percentage, always produce a net loss. The loss per cent is the square of the common percentage divided by one hundred. This classic result appears in the paper and traps candidates who assume that a profit and an equal loss must cancel out. The reason is that the two articles have different cost prices, so the same percentage acts on different amounts and the loss on the dearer article is larger.
False weights and dishonest dealings are another family of questions. If a dealer uses a weight that is lighter than the true weight, the profit per cent is the error divided by the true weight minus the error, multiplied by one hundred. The idea is that the dealer charges for the true weight but gives less, so the gain is the shortfall measured against what was actually given. Writing the true weight and the false weight clearly, and identifying which is the base, solves every such question.
The selling of a part of a stock at one profit and the rest at another is solved by treating the two parts separately and adding the two selling prices before comparing with the total cost price. The overall profit per cent is the total profit divided by the total cost price, not the average of the two profit percentages, unless the two parts are of equal value. Candidates who average the percentages instead of the profits fall into the same trap as in the chapter on average.
The most common mistakes in this chapter are worth naming. Candidates calculate profit or loss on the selling price instead of the cost price, they calculate discount on the cost price instead of the marked price, they add a profit and a loss percentage without noticing that the bases differ, and they forget the product term in successive changes. Each of these is a small slip with a large consequence, and each is avoided by writing down which price is the base before any calculation.
Profit and loss rewards a candidate who is methodical rather than clever. Reading the question twice, writing the three prices in a small table, and deciding which percentage acts on which base will solve almost every question in the paper. The arithmetic is light and the reasoning is short, so with a week of practice the chapter becomes a dependable source of marks, and the confidence it gives carries over into the chapters on percentage, ratio and simple interest.
The profit and loss are calculated on the cost price. If an article is sold for more than the cost price, the difference is the profit, and if it is sold for less, the difference is the loss. The profit per cent and the loss per cent are always calculated on the cost price, and this is the single most important rule of the topic. The candidate should never calculate the profit per cent on the selling price unless the question says so.
The selling price is the cost price plus the profit, or the cost price minus the loss. The cost price is the selling price minus the profit, or the selling price plus the loss. If the profit per cent is p, then the selling price is the cost price into one hundred plus p, divided by one hundred, and if the loss per cent is l, then the selling price is the cost price into one hundred minus l, divided by one hundred. These two formulas answer most of the questions.
The candidate should remember the relation between the profit per cent and the loss per cent when the selling price is the same. If two articles are sold at the same selling price, one at a profit of p per cent and the other at a loss of p per cent, then there is always a loss, and the loss per cent is p squared by one hundred. This is a favourite question, and the answer is always a loss, never a profit, which surprises many candidates.
The topic also includes the marked price and the discount. The marked price is the price written on the article, and the discount is a reduction on the marked price. The selling price is the marked price minus the discount, and the discount per cent is calculated on the marked price. If a shopkeeper marks an article above the cost price and then gives a discount, the profit per cent is calculated on the cost price, and the candidate should follow the order of the operations carefully.
The false weight and the dishonest dealer form another type of question. If a dealer uses a weight that is less than the true weight, the profit per cent is the difference between the true weight and the false weight, divided by the false weight, multiplied by one hundred. If a dealer mixes a cheaper article with a dearer one and sells the mixture at the price of the dearer one, the profit per cent can be found by the alligation method.
The topic is closely related to the percentage and the alligation. A candidate who is comfortable with the percentage can solve the profit and loss questions quickly, because the profit per cent, the loss per cent and the discount are all percentages. The candidate should also know how to find the cost price when the selling price and the profit per cent are given, and how to find the selling price when the cost price and the profit per cent are given.
- Profit is selling price minus cost price; loss is cost price minus selling price.
- Profit per cent and loss per cent are always calculated on the cost price.
- Discount is always calculated on the marked price.
- A profit of r per cent multiplies the cost price by one plus r over one hundred.
- Two articles sold at the same price, one at a profit and one at an equal loss, give a net loss of the square of the common percentage over one hundred.
- Successive discounts are combined by multiplying their multipliers, not by adding the rates.
- The overall profit per cent is total profit divided by total cost price.
- Profit or loss per cent is always calculated on the cost price.
- SP = CP(100 + p)/100 for profit p%; SP = CP(100 - l)/100 for loss l%.
- Two articles sold at the same price, one at p% profit and the other at p% loss: net loss = p²/100 %.
- Discount is calculated on the marked price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is discount calculated on the marked price and not the cost price?
Because the marked price is the price the seller displays to the buyer, and a discount is a concession on that displayed price.
Why does a profit and an equal loss on two articles give a net loss?
Because the two articles have different cost prices, so the same percentage acts on different amounts and the loss on the dearer article is larger.
How are two successive discounts combined?
Multiply their multipliers: a discount of d per cent gives the factor one minus d over one hundred, and the two factors are multiplied together.
On which price is the profit per cent calculated?
The profit per cent is always calculated on the cost price.
What is the net result if two articles are sold at the same price, one at p% profit and the other at p% loss?
There is always a net loss of p²/100 per cent.